The Ultimate Guide to Thrifting in the Hudson Valley

By: Libby Clark

Thrifting isn’t just about finding unique pieces—it’s a treasure hunt, a way to save money, and a step toward a more sustainable wardrobe. While many Marist fashion majors are already familiar with the local thrift scene, there is always more to explore. If you're new to thrifting or looking to discover new spots, this guide will take you through the best thrift and vintage shops in the Hudson Valley, along with essential tips for scoring the best finds.

Where to Thrift in the Hudson Valley

Poughkeepsie:

Under the Stars Resale & Vintage

• A solid mix of vintage and modern secondhand pieces

• Best finds: Leather jackets and cute shoes

Plato’s Closet (Newly Opened)

• Trend-focused resale shop with affordable prices

• Great for name brands, workout clothes, and everyday staples

Rhinebeck:

The Clothes Tree

• Higher-end consignment shop with a mix of vintage and designer pieces

• Best finds: Cozy sweaters, furs, and a wide selection of shoes

New Paltz

Nettle & Violet

• A curated vintage store with quality pieces at fair prices

• Best finds: Leather boots in every style

Water Street Market

• A collection of small shops with clothing, posters, and vintage knickknacks

• Ideal for finding hidden gems beyond just clothes

Hyde Park:

Hyde Park Consignments

• Clothing, furniture, books, and other secondhand items

Wappinger Falls:

Goodwill

• Better than average Goodwill store

• Lots of good name brands

How to Thrift Like a Pro

Finding the best pieces takes patience, strategy, and a little bit of luck. Here are some go-to tips for navigating the Hudson Valley’s thrift and vintage scene:

• Make it an experience. Grab a coffee, put on a good playlist, and prepare to spend time digging through racks. The best finds take effort.

• Look at everything. Don’t just skim the surface—dig deep through racks, check bins, and don’t be afraid to get a little messy.

• Check unexpected sections. The children’s section has great crop tops, the men’s section is a goldmine for oversized blazers, and the lingerie aisle often has silk slip dresses that are perfect for going out.

• Be mindful of quality.

  • Check tags for fabric content—natural fibers like wool, silk, and cotton last longer.

  • Inspect for stains and damage. If you find a flaw, ask for a discount. Many imperfections can be fixed or upcycled.

  • Old shoes can be risky. Vintage leather is great, but cheaply made older shoes can crack and fall apart. It is worth checking the soles and structure before buying.

• Read washing instructions. Vintage pieces may require hand-washing or dry cleaning, so be prepared to care for them properly.

• Don't buy just for the brand. A designer label does not always mean it is worth it—if you don’t love it, leave it.

• Check the fitting room racks. Some of the best finds end up here after people decide not to buy them.

• Be open to DIY. If the color is wrong, dye it. If it is ripped, patch it. If its not your size, get your fashion design major to tailor it. Some of the best pieces can be transformed with a little creativity.

• The most important rule: If you don’t love it, don’t buy it. It is easy to get carried away, but make sure each piece truly excites you before taking it home.

Why Thrifting is Worth It

Beyond the thrill of the hunt, thrifting is a sustainable and budget-friendly way to shop. Buying secondhand reduces waste, supports local businesses, and allows you to build a wardrobe that is unique and personal. There is also nothing better than someone asking, “Where did you get that?” and knowing it is a one-of-a-kind find.

Whether you are an experienced thrifter or just starting, the Hudson Valley has plenty of hidden gems waiting to be discovered. Happy hunting.